Blow for Lambeth Momentum as sitting councillors win re-selection

Supporters of Jeremy Corbyn in Lambeth have failed to bring about the de-selection of three Labour councillors, with party members in the Gypsy Hill ward voting decisively in favour of the trio defending their seats at next year’s borough election.

A close outcome had been anticipated in a branch chaired since November by veteran left winger Ted Knight, a former leader of Lambeth Council, and where membership has increased dramatically as part of the “Corbyn surge“, but Councillors Matthew Bennett, Jennifer Brathwa and Luke Murphy all won comfortably, by 28-16, 34-14 and 30-17 respectively.

The outcome is a disappointment for Momentum, the group formed to support Corbyn, which has been conspicuous in the south London borough and critical of local Labour politicians it has termed “Blairite” or as affiliated to the Progress wing of the party. Lambeth Momentum derided the selection of Murphy to contest Gypsy Hill at the by-election he won last year ahead of two Corbyn supporters, describing him as a “Progress favourite” and appearing to be more enthusiastic about the Green Party candidate.

A meeting to launch the Lambeth branch of Momentum in December 2015 was attended by Knight and shadow chancellor John McDonnell, another prominent figure in the Left’s rise to power in London local government in the 1980s. Knight was eventually barred from holding public office for refusing to set a legal budget as part of a revolt against the Conservative government’s rate-capping policy, which set limits on councils’ freedom to raise local property taxes. He had previously been expelled from Labour in the mid-1950s because of his connections with a far Left group.

Gypsy Hill is among the last of Lambeth’s wards to complete its candidate selection process for the 2018 elections. Bennett, the council’s cabinet member for housing, has come under concerted pressure from campaigners opposing council policies on housing estate redevelopment.

The Town Hall’s approach to local libraries and the Garden Bridge have been other contentious issues, but Lambeth leader Lib Peck and other senior councillors have also prevailed in their ward selection ballots. Bennett has expressed delight with the Gypsy Hill results and said on Twitter that for him and his two colleagues it was “great to have the strong backing of local members”.



Categories: News


  1. Lambeth set to give go-ahead for estate demolition and rebuild – Dave Hill ON LONDON says:

    […] represents. However, earlier this month he and his two fellow Labour councillors for the area were comfortably re-selected by branch party members to defend their seats in next year’s borough […]

  2. Cllr Matthew Bennett selected to stand for Labour in Gypsy Hill ward for 2018 Lambeth Council elections says:

    […] can read a little more about the Gypsy Hill ward selections via Dave Hill’s new London blog. It is disappointing that Dave chooses to lead with old political battles – an issue that […]

  3. Andrew Sherman says:

    Poor Dave, opening your piece with spin. Old habits die hard, don’t they? Has it occurred to you that there could be sound reasons to NOT de-select them?

    The meeting was “packed”. Of the 50-ish people who turned up to vote, about 30 of them hadn’t been to a party meeting for over 12 months. I remember the “good old days” when people like yourself would rant and rave about the “packing” of meetings by the left, but when it’s yer “realists” doing it, there’s nary a squawk from you or your ideological fellow-travellers.

    I have no time for Momentum – their “solutions” to an overly-centrist Labour Party are as anile and as redolent of wishful thinking as anything they rail against – but you appear to miss the point that historically what’s important is to capture the structures of the party, not to put figureheads like Luke “my nan lived in a council flat” Murphy in place. Now, who’s captured the position of Chair for Gipsy Hill branch, again?

  4. mckee1917 says:

    Dave Hill failed to mention Progress favourite Luke Murphy managed to turn an 1800 solid majority in Gipsy Hill into a marginal 38 majority. Will the three Progress candidates deliver a similar stunning result for Labour in May 2018 or something even worse?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *