Russell Curtis: The London Plan and the challenges of Green Belt building

Russell Curtis: The London Plan and the challenges of Green Belt building

The Green Belt is the Marmite of planning policy. For some, the very idea of building homes on the verdant fringes of towns and cities propels them into paroxysms of rage. For others, the rules protecting Green Belt land are exasperating anachronisms that are a major drag on growth. The truth, as so often, lies somewhere in between.

For most of his time as Mayor, Sadiq Khan has been firmly against building on the parts of the Green Belt that fall within Greater London. He campaigned against it when he first sought election in 2016, and in 2021 said it “serves multiple important functions for our city [and] should be protected from inappropriate development”. But four years later, he began to argue that a reliance on brownfield land alone was “wrong, out-of-date and simply unsustainable”. City Hall’s new position would be to “actively explore the release of parts of London’s Green Belt for development”.

Behind the change of heart was the outcome of the 2024 general election. Labour’s victory meant that for the first time in eight years London regional government was in politically aligned with national government. Prior to that, the relationship between Khan and the Conservatives in Westminster had been pugnacious and self-defeating. But now there was an opportunity to coordinate planning and housing policies at a time when they were due for renewal. In theory, like a key turning in a lock, this should have been the solution London’s dire housing shortages. but how is it working in practice?

***

The planning process in England is a top-down system which determines what types of development should happen where and ultimately how planning applications should be determined by local authorities. In London, that means the 32 borough councils and the City of London, along with the three Mayoral Development Corporations, which cover the Olympic Park, Old Oak and Park Royal and, a new addition, the Oxford Street Development Corporation.

At the tip of the pyramid is the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF), which sets out the government’s overarching requirements. Below it are regional spatial policies, including the Mayor’s London Plan. At the base of the pyramid are the local authorities’ Local Plans. Each of these three tiers should, in theory, be in broad conformity with each other, although for reasons of politics and timing complete calibration is rare.

In line with its manifesto commitments, the new government’s NPPF, first adopted in December 2024 and revised in August of this year, codifies a range of planning policies for Green Belt development and housebuilding.

First is the introduction of what has been termed “grey belt”, which includes “disused petrol stations, abandoned car parks [and] low-value scrub land”, as housing secretary Matthew Pennycook described it. However, although the focus was on scrappy plots that happened to be classified as Green Belt, the definition is actually much broader, covering any spaces – brown, green or grey – which fail to meet specific NPPF criteria.

The second relevant policy is “automatic approval” for housing around the country’s railway stations. The NPPF sets out required densities derived from rather opaque transport and economic characteristics: at least 35 or 45 homes per hectare, depending on train frequency. Whether the station lies within the Green Belt or not, those rules still apply. And whilst not explicit in the policy, it is generally understood that areas within 800 metres (roughly ten minutes’ walk) from the station should be developable. The precise locations of these “well-connected stations”, as they’re described, remain the subject of debate.

Meanwhile, Mayor Khan has reached a similar conclusion in that his draft new London Plan promotes the idea of high density development close to public transport which, in the capital, includes Underground as well as railway stations, along with tram stops. At the same time, his proposed policy is both much more targeted and significantly more ambitious.

Rather than adopting a criteria-based approach to development, the draft Plan identifies ten specific locations for Green Belt release. It calls these Broad Locations of Growth (BLGs). Nine suburban boroughs are targeted, with eight of these expected to between them build thousands of homes on Green Belt land in their areas.

There are further differences between the NPPF and the draft London Plan proposals when it comes to specific requirements for developing around stations. The Mayor’s policy extends the NPPF’s 800 metres to 1,200 – roughly 15 minutes’ walk, rather than 10. The housing densities it requires also far exceed those set out at national level.

Sensibly, these vary according to proximity: 160 homes per hectare within 480 metres; 130  per hectare at up to 800 metres; and 90 beyond that up to 1,200 metres. Even within the intermediate band, this figure is nearly three times that of the government’s requirements. In addition, the draft Plan proposes a range of recommended building heights, from six floors within the inner ring to four in the outer.

***

Housing density is a rather abstract concept. In simple terms, Greater London’s median density is around 32 homes per hectare of land, but there are wide variations. In 60 per cent of the capital, density falls below 40 homes per hectare. The Victorian terraced streets of inner London are typically in the 40-50 range, while in most of suburban London it is between 10 and 20. Compare those figures with the 160 per hectare required by the draft new London Plan. Only a very small number of neighbourhoods, in Tower Hamlets, Chelsea and Maida Vale, get anywhere near it.

All in all, there are 50 suburban London Underground stations and tram stops covered by the policy. Of these, only one liessouth of the river, extending along the tram line between East Croydon and New Addington. The rest of south London is left alone, although Bromley is identified as a future candidate when (and if) the Bakerloo line gets extended to Hayes in the coming decades.

The remaining nine BLGs span from Hillingdon to Havering around the northern arc of Greater London. In Barnet, a horseshoe of Green Belt-adjacent stations along the fork of the Northern line are expected to yield 7,000 homes in a borough which also has the highest absolute Green Belt housing target of 25,730. Hillingdon must find nearly two thirds of its total target of 22,920 on its Green Belt. Most of this is around the Metro-land areas of Ruislip, with the two Northwood stations forming the western part of the BLG it shares with Harrow.

Chipping barnet green belt
Chipping barnet green belt

Most of Enfield’s 7,000 home target will likely be found around Crews Hill, one of the locations selected for two New Towns in London, although there are other pockets of land around the final two stations along the Piccadilly line, Oakwood and Cockfosters the Mayor is keen to see developed. What the impact of the New Town will be isn’t yet apparent. The government’s proposal is for it to have 21,000 homes in the end – three times as many as the draft new London Plan proposes. Perhaps the difference in those figures reflects a tacit acknowledgement that completion of the New Town is more than a decade away.

Redbridge’s figure is relatively modest at 5,400 homes, but all of these need to be found along the Eastern Hainault Loop from which the BLG gets its name. There are just four stations in this short run from Newbury Park to Hainault itself, and the available Green Belt land is very limited. Almost all of it is within or around Fairlop Waters, a country park.

The various lines heading into Essex through Barking & Dagenham and Havering form the final three BLGs. Harold Park’s name is a conflation of the two station names at Gidea Park and Harold Wood on the Elizabeth line. The only parts of the Green Belt close to either of those are Romford Golf Course and the area around Harold Wood Park. The rest of Havering’s 12,060 Green Belt homes will need to be found in the proximity of Upminster, where the second of the borough’s three BLGs is to be found. This overlaps with the Dagenham BLG where the only Green Belt territory flanks the River Beam (also known as the River Rom).

All in all, over the next 10 years, the eight boroughs with specific Green Belt targets must find space for 56,100 homes within spaces they’d previously believed were sacrosanct. That’s around 10 per cent of London’s total ten-year target of 558,000, a number that’s well below the government’s expectation of 850,000 – another area where the draft new London Plan deviates from national policy.

***

Aside from inevitable political opposition all this will attract, there are further challenges ahead. One will be developers’ reluctance to build homes at the densities required of them. In the current market, flats are costly to build and difficult to sell, so family houses are the only game in town. Yet building houses alone won’t get anywhere near the densities required. These pressures will ease in time, but to place so much reliance on densities which can only be achieved with mid-rise apartments is a gamble.

It’s inevitable that the Plan will face opposition from both Nimbys and Yimbys: from both those who face the loss of green spaces around the city’s edges and those who think it doesn’t go far enough to deliver the homes the city so obviously needs. The government may well have something to say, as the Mayor’s total housing target falls well short of the figure it expects him to deliver. The consultation closes on 15 October, with every significant organisation in the capital expected to submit a representation. Watch this (green) space.

Russell Curtis is the founding director of architectural practice RCKa and a Mayor’s design advocate. Follow him on Bluesky. Both the map t the top and the photo of Chipping Barnet Green Belt land in the middle are the work of Russell.

OnLondon.co.uk is funded by sales of publisher and editor Dave Hill’s twice-weekly newsletter On London Extra. To start receiving it, become a paying subscriber to Dave’s personal Substack. Thanks.

Categories: Analysis