Back in July last year, a new skirmish over heritage protection versus development in the City of London broke out. It was instigated not by the usual “heritage lobby” suspects but by the City Corporation itself. It had Historic England in its sights, accusing the quango of undermining vital economic growth with its “persistent” objections to new tall buildings. Just over 12 months on, the Guildhall is celebrating what looks like a decisive victory, with significant implications for the Square Mile’s skyline.
The key battleground was the City’s looming “eastern cluster” of skyscrapers, which Historic England argued was increasingly impinging on the Tower of London, one of the capital’s four world heritage sites. It took particular aim at what it saw as over-permissive height guidelines for the cluster as set out in the Corporation’s City Plan 2040, the planning blueprint for the area.
A more “deferential” approach was proposed to increase “visual separation” between the Tower and its surroundings. Planning minister Matthew Pennycook was persuaded enough to order the inspectors conducting the public examination into the Plan to take a second look.
The outcome wasn’t good news for the heritage body. The inspectors concluded that the Guildhall proposals struck the “most appropriate balance” between protecting the Tower and “avoiding undue restrictions on economic growth”. Pennycook has professed himself reassured by their findings, paving the way for the new City Plan to come into effect.
It’s a big decision, sanctioning perhaps as many as 20 proposals for skyscrapers in the east of the City, creating a potential 6,800 jobs and generating £1.2 billion every year in economic output, which the Guildhall argues, would otherwise have been foregone. And the Corporation is seeking to capitalise further on the win. Estimating that up to three million square metres of extra office space could be needed by 2050, it is calling for Sadiq Khan’s draft new London Plan, out for consultation until the middle this month, to add Broadgate and an area north of Fleet Street to its list of locations suitable for “metropolitan scale” buildings of over 100 metres in height.
A construction free for all then? Not quite. Guildhall decision-makers must still consider individual planning applications on their merits, including by taking into account their heritage impact on protected buildings and conservation areas, along with design and other issues. There’s still a presumption of “retrofit”, and the Corporation, according to its policy chair Chris Hayward, has “consistently argued that economic growth and heritage conservation must go hand in hand…the objective has always been to protect what makes London special while ensuring the capital can continue to grow”.
As ever in the planning world, it’s all about balance. Anyone who follows planning decisions will be familiar with those sometimes abstruse-sounding arguments as to whether a development might cause “substantial” or “less than substantial” harm to a protected building or conservation area, and to what degree, all before weighing that against “any public benefits resulting from the proposal”, as the new national planning policy puts it. Critically, all of this remains a matter of planning judgment for the decision maker.
In the historic Square Mile, with its narrow lanes, Roman substructure, 48 churches, 28 conservation areas and more than 600 listed buildings amid its towers, plus the restrictions placed by City Hall’s long-standing rules protecting long-range views of St Paul’s Cathedral, that’s not straightforward, even before factoring in high construction costs that threaten viability.
The Mayor of London’s “call-in” remit extends into the Corporation’s domain. Pennycook’s confirmation, while nodding through the City Plan, that new provisions in the 2023 Levelling-up and Regeneration Act 2023 requiring local authorities to have “special regard” to the protection of world heritage sites, including the Tower of London, will be brought into force, adds a potential further barrier to development.
With demand for top-quality Square Mile space still significantly outstripping supply, the Guildhall nevertheless continues to bet on encouraging office developments. And in its constrained environment, pretty much the only way is up. This matters to everyone concerned about the City’s skyline and its ground level heritage too, and has the effect of making the role of Historic England, which is a statutory consultee on applications with major heritage implications, all the more important despite its recent knock-back by the inspectors and the minister.
That importance of that role is all the greater due to the City having only a small number of residents, and therefore lacking a cadre of concerned citizens which might otherwise be relied on to ensure that potentially contentious applications don’t come forward unnoticed. The recent battle may have been lost, but vigorous debate over development in the historic heart of the capital will no doubt continue. Next year’s examination in public of the draft new London Plan looks set to be scene for the next one.
Follow Charles Wright on Bluesky. Photo from Eastern City.
OnLondon.co.uk is funded by sales of publisher and editor Dave Hill’s twice-weekly newsletter On London Extra. To receive it, become a paying subscriber to Dave’s personal Substack. Thanks.